No, this isn't a post about MC. This is a post about raiding status. Core Raider is a term I've seen used in a few guilds now, referring to those players that are better geared and more experienced than other guild members. I don't have any problem with this per se, in fact I am a core raider in my current guild, however I don't think it automatically means "better player".
Raiding requires a couple of things to succeed. It needs gear, obviously, as well as knowledge of the encounter (move here, run away if you are the bomb, etc.). It also needs the player to be able to play their class. There Is no point being a fully epic'd hunter if you only use auto shot and have a crap pet. This is where the problem lies.
A lot of people track stats in game. There's even a website (
WoW Web Stats). It is possible to do decent dps if you have top gear without really maximizing your output. The same with healing, and you can be an awesomely geared tank that gets the job done but doesn't position mobs well (which generally goes unnoticed). The stats don't show the little things.
So people who top meters and show up every raid tend to get promoted to core raiders. No problems there, they should be rewarded for their effort. However, this does not automatically make them better players than people who are just beginning to gear up. Unfortunately, core raiders usually look down on other players as inferior.
I don't think the best players are those that are better geared, the best players are those that make others better. It's the same with sports; LeBron James is a great basketball player not only because he can do amazing things on court, but because he makes his team mates better by encouraging them, having confidence in their ability, and giving them easy shots.
To be a great WoW player you need to not only know the game, but share that knowledge. You need to have patience as others learn encounters, even if they wipe you ten times, and confidence in their ability to get it sooner or later. You need to be prepared to run an instance over and over again to help gear up others even though there is nothing that will upgrade you. You need to ignore dps numbers (most of the time) and offer advice and tips to improve. You need to listen to othersconcetns and issues and offer solutions if possible. You need to keep spirits up with encouragement and jokes (it is just a game after all). Basically, you need to be in it for more than just the epix.